An acclaimed author, a leading scholar of the American frontier, has authored a new volume titled Gunfighters United, which explores the lives of Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday. The historian expresses frustration with the famous phrase from a renowned cowboy film: “When the legend becomes truth, print the legend.”
“Every researcher cites it, they just overuse it,” Gardner says cheerfully. “And it’s really not correct. I composed a story. I aim people to be absorbed in the period, but I just get so tired of that line. The myth is legend. It won't become fact. People can retell the legend but it can't make it truth.”
That Infamous Shootout at the Corral
In the town of Tombstone, on October 26, 1881, Earp and Holliday were involved in a shootout that is remembered as the Tombstone gunfight. Joined by Earp’s brothers, the two met the rustlers, individuals sought for crime and cattle theft. In under 60 seconds, three Cowboys were dead and Doc was hurt, as were the Earp brothers.
Despite being one of many western scraps between lawmen and bandits, it entered legend, not least thanks to famous pictures including the John Ford film and the Sturges movie.
Confusion and Variation in Historical Accounts
“A great deal of what we understand about it is verifiable,” he said of the real fight and its aftermath. “But I repeatedly go back to one of the best quotes, and it’s a very straightforward quote. An observer, who saw the shootout, said: ‘I don’t know. All was confusion.’”
Including the people present had conflicting versions. Statements from the investigation is also murky. Bystanders who were allies of the gang were dishonest, and each account is slightly different. It’s uncommon when anyone aligns on anything.
“It was all a blur.” – a observer
“Including the individuals present were bewildered,” the author continues. “So it’s genuinely challenging to determine it, and it happened in half a minute.”
Legend-Building and Hollywood Depictions
He persisted into the film age, dying in the late 1920s at the age of 80. Originally portrayed on a early cinema film in 1923, he eventually became the subject of significant 20th-century movies. In relatively recent decades, he has been portrayed by a star in Tombstone and another actor in Wyatt Earp.
The historian drills through such legend-building to reveal the people below. His works explore the range of the American frontier, from a legendary figure and Pat Garrett to a civil war guerrilla.
Layered Characters of Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday
Born in the Midwest in 1848, Wyatt was too young to fight in the American Civil War, though he sought to do so. When he was two decades old, he became a constable in a small town. Missteps were made. Earp experienced a calamity with the demise of his wife, Urilla Sutherland, from disease in 1870. Subsequently, as constable, Earp kept revenue he obtained.
“We don't know why he kept it,” Gardner states. “He escapes, and ends up in Indian Territory. He’s detained for taking a horse, and then he’s in the state, and he’s managing a establishment. Finally he heads back out West, and he settles in Wichita, Kansas.”
In spite of his complex history, Wyatt performed well as a peace officer. Newspapers praised him often. In one case, he apprehended a intoxicated man who had money on him. He held the cash for the individual and handed it back when he let go him from confinement.
Divergent Characters of the Duo
The historian highlights the stark contrast between the two. Wyatt was driven, aiming to better himself and attain roles like high office. Doc, hailing in Georgia in 1851, was a dentist turned risk-taker. Different from Wyatt, he did not exhibit indicators of establishing roots.
“He just moves from one gambling place to the following,” he observes. “He never truly transform. And part of that’s his obsession to gambling. Some of that is consumption, dealing with that and treating himself, whether it’s with drink or subsequently medicine.”
Influence and Scholarly Relevance
The new book illustrates a compelling element of the old west: the friction between law and chaos, and the efforts of officials to exert rule over newly forming communities. The degree of bureaucracy that followed a violent incident – hearings, affidavits, orders for payment – might startle those acquainted with simplified depictions of the period.
Furthermore, Wyatt and Holliday were involved in divisive factional conflicts. He was a a conservative, while local lawman his rival was a adversary, creating a competition for influence and authority.
Finally, he avoids to idealize these figures. Earp and Holliday spent time on each side